# Handoff Report — Implementation Track Orchestrator Succession

## Milestone State
- **Milestone 1: Planning & Scope**: DONE
- **Milestone 2: Backend & DB**: IN-PROGRESS (Implementation completed but failed validation review/challenge gate. Needs fixes for route logic, validation schemas, and MCP tool schemas).
- **Milestone 3: Frontend & UI**: PLANNED
- **Milestone 4: Monorepo Build Verification**: PLANNED
- **Milestone 5: E2E Integration**: PLANNED

## Active Subagents
- None (All subagents completed or failed/stopped).

## Pending Decisions / Key Findings
- Reviewer 2 (v2) issued a **FAIL** verdict on M2 implementation. Critical and major issues identified:
  1. PUT Route is non-atomic (Prisma updates to Menu record happen outside transaction block).
  2. POST Route ignores `payload` and `isActive` fields on creation.
  3. PATCH translation endpoint lacks TypeBox schema validation.
  4. Relative imports in routes are missing `.js` extensions under ESM resolution.
  5. GET Route returns a mock object (violating type definition) and 200 OK when menu is not found instead of 404.
  6. Shared types `Menu` interface is missing `isActive`.
  7. Spreading translation array bug in MCP tools `applyMenuAddNode`.
  8. Bypassing type safety with `tx: any`.
- Challenger 1 (v2) issued a **FAIL** verdict on MCP tools integration:
  - Critical omission: `rootImage` parameter is missing from `/home/ti/.gemini/antigravity/mcp/homaroma_mcp/upsert_menu.json` schema, and `columnImage` / `hoverImage` are missing from the `items` sub-schema. This makes the new fields unusable via MCP tools.
- Challenger 2 (v3) issued a **PASS** verdict with notes:
  - Confirmed the API and MCP JSON-RPC layers validate and store the fields correctly at runtime.
  - Warned that the static JSON schemas in `/home/ti/.gemini/antigravity/mcp/homaroma_mcp/` are outdated and need field additions to prevent developer confusion.
  - Identified a duplicate name POST returning 500 instead of 409 Conflict.
- Forensic Auditor (v2) issued a **CLEAN** verdict.

## Remaining Work for Successor
1. Spawn a Worker to implement fixes for all 8 review/challenger issues.
2. Re-run M2 validation (2 Reviewers, 2 Challengers, 1 Forensic Auditor).
3. Once M2 passes, decompose and delegate M3 (Frontend updates in admin, SPA, and website navigation).

## Key Artifacts
- ORIGINAL_REQUEST.md — Verbatim user constraints
- BRIEFING.md — Coordination briefing state
- progress.md — checklist and heartbeat logs
- SCOPE.md — Milestones and contracts
- /home/ti/git/homaroma/.agents/reviewer_m2_2_v2/review.md — Detailed review fail feedback
- /home/ti/git/homaroma/.agents/challenger_m2_1_v2/challenge_report.md — Challenger 1 fail feedback
- /home/ti/git/homaroma/.agents/challenger_m2_2_v3/challenge_report.md — Challenger 2 report & notes